Skip to Main Content
1617 John F. Kennedy Boulevard #355, Philadelphia, PA 19103

What If a Philadelphia Business Says It Has No Video of My Slip and Fall?


You fell in a store, a restaurant, or a building lobby in Philadelphia. You noticed a camera on the ceiling. A few days later, you ask for the video, and the manager says there is none. Maybe it was erased. Maybe it was never saved. Maybe it “just doesn’t exist.”

It is a frustrating moment, and many people think their case is over. It is not. Missing video does not automatically end a slip and fall claim, and in some cases it can even help it. This post explains why video matters, what the law says about deleted footage, and what you can do when a business says the tape is gone.

Why Surveillance Video Matters in a Fall Case

Video can tell the story better than any witness. It can show how you fell, what the floor looked like, and how long the hazard was there. It can also show whether employees walked past it, whether anyone put out a warning sign, and how you were acting right before and after the fall.

That last point matters because property owners often argue that the injured person was careless. Clear video can show you were walking normally, paying attention, and doing nothing wrong. Without it, the case may come down to your word against the business’s word.

For these reasons, video is one of the first things an attorney asks about in a premises liability case. But when it is gone, your claim still has paths forward.

When a Business Can Legally Delete Surveillance Video

It depends on the situation. Many camera systems record over old footage on a loop. Some keep video for as little as a week, and others keep it for a month or longer. A business that overwrites footage as part of a normal routine, before it knew about any injury, may not have done anything wrong.

The picture changes once the business knows or should know that someone was hurt and a claim might follow. At that point, a business may have a duty to keep the video that shows the fall. If it lets the footage disappear after that, a court may take a hard look at what happened.

When the Duty to Keep Video Begins

There is no single moment that always starts this duty, but certain events can point to it. Examples include:

  • A fall that happens on the property
  • An incident report filled out by staff
  • An employee being told about the fall
  • An ambulance or emergency response
  • You asking for medical help or telling staff you are hurt
  • A letter, call, or message about a possible claim

If any of these happened, the business was probably aware that video of the fall could matter. That makes a claim of “we have nothing” harder to accept.

When the Business Says the Video Was Deleted Automatically

This is the most common answer. The business says the system overwrites itself, so nothing was saved. Sometimes that is true. Other times, the explanation does not hold up well.

Courts and lawyers look at questions like these:

  • How long does this system normally keep footage?
  • Could someone have saved a clip once the fall was reported?
  • Did staff know about the injury right away?
  • Was video from other times saved, but not the part showing your fall?
  • Was it easy for the business to keep the clip?

If a business saved footage from before and after your fall but not the fall itself, that raises questions. The same is true if the story changes from one person to the next. Inconsistent explanations can be challenged.

What Spoliation of Evidence Means

Spoliation is a legal word for evidence that is destroyed, changed, lost, or not kept when it should have been. Missing surveillance video is a common example in premises cases.

When a court finds spoliation, it has options. Depending on the facts, a judge may:

  • Order sanctions against the party that lost the evidence
  • Tell the jury it may assume the missing evidence would have hurt that party
  • Limit the defenses that party can use
  • Allow other proof to fill in the gap

These steps can also put pressure on a business to settle. The exact result depends on whether the business had a duty to keep the video, whether it acted carelessly or on purpose, and how much your case was hurt by the loss.

Whether a Jury Can Assume the Video Was Bad for the Business

Possibly. If the business had a duty to keep the footage and lost it without a good reason, a jury may be told it can infer that the video would have helped you and hurt the business. This is sometimes called an adverse inference. It is not guaranteed, and a judge decides whether it fits the facts.

Why Missing Video Does Not Guarantee a Win

No. Even if a business lost the tape, you still have to prove the basics of a slip and fall claim. That means showing the business owed you a duty, that the duty was broken, that the breach caused your fall, and that you suffered real harm.

Under Pennsylvania law, you also generally need to show the business knew about the hazard or should have known about it. Missing video can help here. It can hurt the business’s credibility, weaken a claim that no hazard existed, and support what you and your witnesses say about how long the problem was there.

Other Evidence That Can Take the Place of Video

Without a recording, other proof can carry the case. Useful evidence includes:

  1. Incident reports filled out by the business
  2. Maintenance and cleaning logs that show when the area was last checked
  3. Employee schedules that show who was working
  4. Witness statements from customers or staff
  5. Photos or video you or someone else took right after the fall
  6. Weather records, especially for falls near entrances
  7. Records of earlier complaints or similar falls in the same spot
  8. Your medical records, bills, and notes about your recovery

A business that has no maintenance log, no cleaning record, and no video may have a hard time showing it kept the property safe. That gap can work in your favor.

What to Do Right After a Fall

Moving fast gives you the best chance of keeping evidence alive. If you can do so safely, take these steps:

  1. Report the fall to the manager or owner, and ask for an incident report.
  2. Ask whether cameras cover the area, and ask that the footage be saved.
  3. Take photos of the hazard, the surrounding area, your shoes, and your injuries.
  4. Get names and numbers for witnesses.
  5. Write down the date, time, and exact location.
  6. Get medical care right away, even if you think the injury is small.
  7. Keep your receipts, records, and notes.
  8. Do not sign anything or give a recorded statement to an insurer before you understand your rights.

Asking about the video early matters. A request made on the day of the fall, or soon after, makes it harder for a business to say it did not know the video was important.

How Insurance Companies Use Missing Video

After a fall, the business’s insurer may take over the claim. When there is no video, the insurer may say:

  • The footage never existed
  • The system overwrote it as part of a normal routine
  • The footage would not have shown anything helpful

Some of these statements may be true. Others may not be. An attorney can ask for records about the camera system, such as how long it keeps video and when the area was last recorded. That can show whether the explanation matches the facts.

Why Acting Quickly Matters

Lost video cannot be brought back. Many systems overwrite footage in a matter of days, so waiting even a few weeks can mean the recording is gone. An attorney can act right away to protect evidence by:

  • Sending a letter that tells the business to keep all video and records
  • Asking for information about the camera system and how it stores footage
  • Spotting spoliation issues early
  • Gathering other proof before it is lost

In Pennsylvania, you also have a limited time to file a lawsuit, generally two years from the date of your fall. Claims against government bodies can have much shorter notice periods. Waiting can hurt both your evidence and your rights.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a business have to give me the video of my fall?

Not automatically. A business does not have to hand over footage just because you ask. But if you bring a claim, the video can be requested in the legal process, and if it was lost after the business knew about your fall, a court may look closely at why.

Can a business legally delete surveillance video?

Yes, if it did so as part of a normal routine and had no reason to know a claim might come. The situation changes once the business knows or should know that someone was hurt. After that point, deleting the video can lead to serious problems for the business.

What if the business only saved part of the video?

That can be a red flag. If footage from before or after your fall was kept but the fall itself was not, a court may ask why. Selective saving can raise concerns about whether evidence was kept on purpose or lost on purpose.

Can I still win my slip and fall case without video?

Yes. Many cases are built on witness statements, incident reports, maintenance records, photos, and medical records. You still have to prove your claim, but missing video does not stop you from doing so.

Should I talk to an attorney if the business says the video is gone?

Yes, and as soon as you can. An attorney can send a preservation letter, ask for records about the camera system, and look for signs of lost or hidden evidence.

Talk to a Philadelphia Slip and Fall Attorney

A business that says it has no video of your fall has not ended your case. What happened after your injury, and what the business did with the footage, can matter just as much as the tape itself. Philly Slip and Fall Guys can look into the camera system, push for the records, and build your claim with the evidence that is still available. Call 215-268-6898 for a free consultation to talk about your fall and what you can do next.